PC Adventure games—the other reality

Posted on February 5, 2009. Filed under: Culture, Games, Health, Musings, Philosophy |

Haven’t done a game post for a while. This one’s probably more about philosophy than games, per se, though. I’m usually playing a PC game in my off-hours—or minutes. My preferences are for PC adventure games; which are not as prominent as war games or multi-player games, so it can be a challenge to find good ones.

Most recently, I got ’round to playing Dreamfall, the sequel to Ragnar TΓΈrnquist’s The Longest Journey. There are many, many reviews around for these games, so I will briefly describe my gameplay impressions towards the end of the post, but first will describe how this medium affects my philosophy and psychology.

For me, the story in an adventure game is the most important element. Puzzles are OK, sometimes fun, and sometimes even necessary to advance the plot, but I’m there for the tale. All of my favorite games have characters and scenes an average, civilized (?) 21st-century person can relate to, but have fantasy, sci-fi, or mystical elements to them; sometimes all three. So, why don’t I just read a good fantasy novel instead?, you ask. (I hear you.) I do that, too. It’s just that getting a story through a game environment is different, just as seeing a movie is different from reading the same story in a book. In the best games, the player is making choices about where to go when; who to talk to; what to talk about; and the pacing is controlled by them. Of course in reading a novel, one can put the book down and come back when one chooses, unlike in a film where one generally sits through from beginning to end. One can even skip ahead in a novel, although I rarely do this in practice. If the book isn’t compelling enough for me to read straight through as the author intended, I generally stop reading. For the most part, both novels and movies are plotted as in this advice, given to a character in a novel about how to tell a story: “Start at the beginning, go on ’til you reach the end, and then stop!” πŸ˜‰

Although game stories are generally, really, as linearly laid out as a film, they at least give the illusion that the choices the player makes matter. In some games, they actually really do—the player will arrive at a different destination, or reach a different conclusion based upon her/his choices. However in most of them one proceeds through the story in a particular order. What’s different, though, is the ability to explore. Among my first game playing experiences was the Myst series, and I loved that I could go in and out of buildings as many times as I wanted to, look around as much as I liked, and make the next move or solve the next puzzle only when I was ready. It was immersive. I was there.

Which is both the “blessing and the curse”. I tend to be a bit reclusive, and have always lived somewhat in my own fantasy world. I’m one of those players who can sit in a darkened room for hours with my game, and completely forget the rest of the word exists—if indeed it does. ❗ I could, probably, when the technology evolves enough, substitute “virtual reality” for “real reality” (Is that redundant? IS reality real?). I find this both comforting and alarming. On the one hand, if I someday become old, πŸ˜‰ and have frightened off all my friends, I can live in the virtual world a lot of the time, and be quite content. On the other hand, psychologists say this sort of thinking is very bad for us, has already shifted morals and expectations, and will cause the collapse of society as we know it.

In case you’re concerned, please know that I work with people; I’m active in organizations with people; I sing with people—all of which I find very satisfying and have no desire to give up. It’s just that…I’m not sure I NEED actual other human beings around me to be content. I even have a bit of a relationship with “Clippy” that cute annoying ubiquitous paper clip who is meant to be my “helper” in Microsoft WORD. I can just imagine that once “Virtual Reality” evolves, with the goggles and the pressure suits, and all, you MIGHT not see me for a week at a time. And I’m not sure how I feel about that.

Given all that, though, I still have to say it was the story in Dreamfall which was the most compelling thing about it. I won’t talk about the plot too much in case you want to play it and haven’t, but I found it deeply moving, and I cared about what would happen next, to characters I’d come to value. (Dreamfall did not have a “Hollywood Ending”; there will be sequels.) While there are a few novels I’ve read more than once, and feel are my old friends, Dreamfall was different in that I could virtually go to some of my favorite locations and “visit” my favorite characters. They became friends. After playing it through twice, I’d start up the game and go directly to my favorite town, and listen to my favorite dialogue. After a few days of this, though, I began to realize this world had become a little TOO real. I went “cold turkey”. I uninstalled the game, and put the disc on the shelf. I know I will come back someday, but, it felt, for a while, like I kept going back to the same little town on a vacation, instead of moving on to a new place. Now, I’m in Egypt, on another adventure, and while the story is not nearly as compelling, I at least remember where I am, in the rest of the world, while I’m playing.

OK, here comes the “Game Review” portion of the post. Feel free to skip it, if, in spite of all my pleading and cajoling you still refuse to play adventure games! πŸ˜›

Dreamfall has been out for about three years now, which makes it aged by gaming standards. Its predecessor, The Longest Journey, had been called “the best adventure game of all time” by many reviewers. I’d read a lot about TLJ before playing it, and it turned out to be very different than I thought it would be. This is often the case when I visit a new city or country, too. Only the Yorkshire Moors were pretty much as I’d imagined them, after reading all those English novels set there.

Strictly from a gaming point of view, I thought Longest Journey was better than Dreamfall. By a lot! (A few rather silly and somewhat pointless puzzles notwithstanding.) Adventure gamers, and particularly PC Adventure gamers are generally not playing these games to engage in fight sequences, whether sword, gun, or hand-to-hand. It’s my supposition that Mr. TΓΈrnquist put in a number of those widely talked about and almost universally disliked sequences to attract a larger audience. I’d like to start a petition amongst 12-year-old boys in which they will say the following:Β  “I, _____(name of 12-year-old boy) will never buy an adventure game no matter what you do to it, so you might as well take out the fight scenes so the real AG’ers will buy it.” Β  Do you think that would do the trick?

The other thing about gameplay in Dreamfall is that I, and I suspect many AG’ers have a few physical…issues, such as dyslexia, and less than optimal coordination. This is not a problem in most AGs, as most of the “action” involves mouse-pointing and clicking. I can do that! In Dreamfall, there are several timed puzzles, which I don’t generally like (with the “coordination issues” it’s often difficult for me to complete the required action in “time”; very frustrating) and there was one particular puzzle I never could beat. I actually had to search for and load another player’s saved game to get past that part; the first time I’d EVER had to do that in an adventure game. Otherwise, I’d have had to quit about 2/3 of the way through. Hints and walkthroughs are of no assistance in this situation—I knew WHAT to do, I just couldn’t do it quickly enough. And got killed. Again. And again. And… I also think it’s silly to get killed a lot in adventure games—I mean, once or twice is OK, but, really, that’s not what I’m there for. It was sad for me in this case because the player in the other person’s game I loaded had made a different choice early in the game which didn’t allow me to experience one of the very touching story moments I otherwise would have, although I did find the scene in a YouTube video eventually. I felt cheated, though. The scene wasn’t there for ME!

Ah, but the story; the story! It made it all worthwhile. It was philosophically and spiritually challenging, and made me re-think some suppositions in my belief system. The very best novels and films do that as well. The underlying premise is that, underneath everyday reality, there is “the dreaming” which causes the world, and all of us, to be. This is somewhat like some parts of Native Australian belief, but is done a bit differently here. The tag line of the game is: “The Undreaming is Unchained“. What do we make of that? Perhaps the sequels will tell.

Make a Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

18 Responses to “PC Adventure games—the other reality”

RSS Feed for MusEditions Comments RSS Feed

Sounds like a good game, Muse. I like adventure games. I rarely play them, but do enjoy them. I don’t like when they add in the fighting. I’m with you! Give us a real adventure game with none of that junk. If you find one, let me know. πŸ™‚

Now this post hit home!

I am addicted to Zelda: Twilight Princess. MAAAAAAAAAAN!

I have spent way too many hours on that – but it has hooked me, literally, hook, line and sinker. Alison and I used to play online games, but got bored with them – silliness and became, well, too political – ironic? LOL

But I do love this game – it isn’t just a matter of fighting the bad guy, it’s a real story. It’s all about doing quests and actually thinking things through.

I could go on, so if you want a recommendation – I would get it. Tis fun. πŸ™‚

I am not into gaming of any form…ok I am addicted to scrabble on facebook πŸ™‚
I have to learn how to be content without humans around me. A lesson please cos I probably am looking at a life like that in the future! 😦

I’ve always been a big fan of the Nintendo systems and games. I never really have played many games on the PC though.

I was always big into the Zelda games, sitting and playing them for hours a day trying to beat them completely. The whole storyline they created for the game was just awesome. It’s just an amazing game(actually series of games) really. I especially love the Zelda: Ocarina of Time. Like Will, I’d recommend Zelda! πŸ™‚

I played Legend of Zelda when Nintendo was new. It was great but still could have done without the fighting.

bead, my favorites can be found here and here. And they are free of charge!

Such enthusiasm, Will. We have another addict here, folks! Call me stodgy, but I am unmotivated to go out and buy yet another device to play games upon, when I have a perfectly good PC! I may cave, though, eventually. πŸ˜‰ I cracked up when I read that online games became too political, hahaha! πŸ˜€ I shall take your recommendation under advisement; thank you.

Scrabble counts, Apar. You can join the club! πŸ˜‰ I’m not so sure that doing without people is a good thing, as I was exploring here. Certainly it’s not a good idea to be dependent on others, but we are, after all, social creatures. πŸ™‚ PS, I don’t believe your last line, so there! πŸ˜€

So, you’re a Nintendo fan, Shane. The game I wrote about here, Dreamfall was originally designed for X-box—even though it’s the sequel to a PC game—and uses X-box-like controls, particularly in the dreaded fight scenes. I was not fond of this, as I am a “point-and-click” sort of person. I borrowed a game controller, but ended up liking the keyboard and mouse better, but it took some getting used to. Since I respect yours and Will’s opinions, I may just have to try a Zelda game; but if I don’t like the fighting… πŸ˜‰

Apparently some game designers don’t think it’s “realistic” for people to have adventures without having to fight someone or something somewhere, BD. But, how “realistic” are these games to begin with? Hah! πŸ˜€

You ask, “What do I make of this post?” I have no idea.

I haven’t played a computer game since Myst, which I loved. For weeks, every time I passed a manhole in nyc I wanted to lift the cover. πŸ˜€

My laptop is too weak for loaded adventure games and I really need to concentrate on earning so I kind of envy you Muse. lol. When I have time, I play Hotel Scape w/c is a combination of memory and adventure game.

Do I? Don’t you? Ah, CuriousC remains curious. πŸ˜‰

ROTFL, ella. No Manhattan manhole is safe from you! If you liked Myst, you simply must try some of my other favorites…unless you’ve actually grown up, unlike some of us. πŸ˜‰

Sometimes I’m playing when I should be working, poch—you wouldn’t envy me when I’m trying to catch up! πŸ™‚ I haven’t experienced Hotel Scape; have to check that one out, thanks!

I like video game storylines, although I mainly play “action-adventures”, which I suspect are precisely the kind you’re less keen on, and I tend to prefer console games over PC games.

I know a lot of people who skip all in-game text, but I always think that takes away a lot of the fun. Whenever I play a video game, I always have to talk to everyone and explore everywhere (which is extremely time consuming, and is probably the reason I no longer play video games very often!). The best thing about adventure games is that you get a whole world to explore!

That said, I also like games for “gameplay”, e.g. action. Zelda has a great story, but I don’t think I’d enjoy it as much without the action sequences.

Well, see, that’s just the thing, B0bby! I have no objection to “action games”, and have even played some “shooters”, and enjoyed them. Mixing it up with adventure play is just…disconcerting, however. I see the adventures as interactive fantasy stories. I agree with you about getting to explore everything! And of course one must explore every little thing and exhaust ALL the dialog!!! That’s the whole point; if you don’t want to do that, you shouldn’t be playing these things, gah! (Not that I have strong opinions or anything.) πŸ˜‰ When I was reading the message boards for Syberia, I noticed a number of impatient players who declared—some quite gleefully—that they skipped through the professor’s lecture at the University! I mean! (Of course if you haven’t played Syberia, you don’t know what I mean, anyway, but it was quite a long lecture and it had important information regarding the story.) You are very right that this is all quite time consuming—but, again, what the heck are you playing these games for??? If you want action, go elsewhere, that’s all I’m saying! πŸ˜€ As you are the 2,438th person to mention Zelda, I suppose I shall have to check her out… πŸ™‚

Hey, I had taken print out of this post so that I could read it unhurried manner. Gaming is very important in my live of work. I am an instructional designer and currently I am working on ‘immersive learning’.

Even your philosophical observations said a lot about the game. Yes, stories and character you can indentify with is very important in a game.

This IS alarmig that one can think of living alone in face of gaming and 3-D environments. But that very fact explains the success of The Second Life and success of all learning programs that use such immersive technology. Guess its normal human reaction.

You did, Poonam? Thank you, I’m honored! I read a novel about immersive technology and machine intelligence called “Society of the Mind”. Interesting book; it shows how the lines between one “reality” and another can blur. It must be fascinating to be working on immersive learning! That, and immersive entertainment are really the wave of the future.

The effect of (immersive) technology on users is now a very hot issue. I wish I could read the book Muse.

It’s a good novel, poch, and surprisingly predictive considering it was written more than 10 years ago.

Muse, I just have to share! I finally found a game I like. I have only played the one hour demo but I think this is one game I will buy. Search for Emerald City Confidential. It’s like a detective game with a Wizard of Oz spin. I like the guy in the white suit πŸ™‚

THANK YOU for sharing this, BD! I looked it up, and it seems just the sort of thing I would like! I loved Oz, and having an adventure game set in that world sounds peachy! And I can play free for an hour? I’ll have to set aside an hour, and let you know how I go on! Thanks again; too fun!

Where's The Comment Form?

Liked it here?
Why not try sites on the blogroll...